10 Fresh Pumpkin Recipes for Fall That Go Beyond Pie

Enjoy the best flavors of autumn—from soup to pie.

beef pumpkin shiitake soup
Photo:

Christopher Testani

The best pumpkins for cooking are very different from those you would choose to decorate. The ubiquitous field pumpkin—the most common variety used in carving—has watery, stringy flesh and isn't recommended for eating. Whether you're choosing to bake a classic pumpkin pie or simmer a large pot of pumpkin soup, you'll want to ask for sugar pumpkins or cheese pumpkins at the market. They're just as widely available, but they're much better suited to cooking and baking thanks to their dense, sweet flesh, and used in these fresh pumpkin recipes.

In their original form, pumpkins can be kept for up to a month in a cool spot in your kitchen. If you want to continue cooking and baking fresh pumpkin recipes closer to the holidays, keep them whole and store them in a cool cellar. That way it can retain its freshness for up to three months. However, once you've cut into a pumpkin, the pieces should be wrapped tightly and refrigerated; you have up to five days to use the flesh and seeds.

Ready to experiment? Follow these fresh pumpkin recipes to enjoy the best flavors of autumn.

01 of 10

Mashed Potatoes With Pumpkin and Greens

mashed-pumpkin-0345-d112647.jpg
Mike Krautter

Give mashed potatoes a colorful, healthy upgrade by adding pumpkin and chard to the mix.

02 of 10

Pumpkin and Pecorino Gratin

med103705_1008_gratin.jpg

Sugar-pumpkin purée is seasoned simply with salt and pepper, then baked under a crown of crunchy breadcrumbs and Romano cheese. This casserole makes a magnificent side dish with roast chicken or pork or a fabulous vegetarian entrée.

03 of 10

Pumpkin Pie

pumpkin pie
Anna Williams

We're sneaking a pie into this collection of fresh pumpkin recipes because it's made with fresh—not canned—pumpkin and is just so good. This pie has a more delicious depth of flavor thanks to the roasted fresh pumpkin and just the right amount of cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg. Make extra purée and freeze it so you can enjoy pumpkin desserts throughout the season.

04 of 10

Roasted Pumpkin

mbd105513_1010_pumpkin20.jpg
Raymond Hom

Our recipe for basic roasted pumpkin is simple and versatile. You can eat the sweet, fibrous flesh straight out of the shell with some olive oil, salt, and pepper, or you can get creative and use the roasted pumpkin flesh for purée or scope out the flesh for other recipes.

05 of 10

Roasted Squash, Apple, and Cipollini Onion Salad

mld105909_1010_salad1.jpg

Though the recipe title says "squash," this recipe can and should be made with sugar pumpkin. It's a hearty winter salad with mellow roasted vegetables and apples contrasting with the peppery watercress.

06 of 10

Roasted Pumpkin Soup

mld105013_1009_pumsoupcard1.jpg

Fresh pumpkin is roasted with onion and shiitake mushrooms, then puréed to make a creamy (but cream-free!) soup. An immersion blender makes quick work of this simple, hearty meal.

07 of 10

Coconut, Fish, and Pumpkin Stew

Caribbean Fish-and-Pumpkin Stew recipe
Lennart Weibull

This lively one-pot dinner features coconut milk, cod, pumpkin (or calabaza), baby spinach, and a touch of chile for a filling and healthy meal.

08 of 10

White Bean and Sausage Stew in Pumpkin Bowls

msl_oct06_15yr_stew.jpg

All dressed up for a fabulous fall dinner party, this hearty stew is baked in sugar pumpkins. A combination of navy beans, turkey sausage, mushrooms, carrots, leeks, potatoes, and peas makes a delicious, filling meal.

09 of 10

Beef, Pumpkin, and Shiitake Soup

beef pumpkin and shiitake soup served with fresh basil
Christopher Testani

Starring sugar pie pumpkin or calabaza, this slowly simmered soupy stew is easy to make. It takes just 15 minutes of prep. When the beef chuck or neck bones are fork-tender, you add the vegetables that won't need long to cook. Fresh basil and a splash of fish sauce are not to be skipped for serving—the latter adds an exceptional hint of umami flavor.

10 of 10

Spiced Pumpkin Seeds

spiced pumpkin seeds
Raymond Hom

Wondering what to do with those pumpkin seeds leftover from your recipes? While you can use store-bought pepitas, try baking or roasting the seeds from fresh pumpkin and season them to your liking, just like we did here with cinnamon, cayenne, cumin, and honey.

Was this page helpful?

Related Articles