News Home & Garden News Find Out How Scary Your City Is With This New Interactive Map Caution, the results might spook you. By Olivia McIntosh Olivia McIntosh Olivia McIntosh is a writer and editor who has worked as a lifestyle content writer and digital marketer since 2020 for B2B and B2C companies. She joined Martha Stewart as an associate editor in September 2024. Editorial Guidelines Published on October 15, 2024 Close Photo: Education Images / Contributor / Getty Images While you might think your neighborhood is the spookiest of all this Halloween season—your town could be tied with a nearby zip code. To settle the debate, Instacart has created a tool to get down to the facts of which cities in the United States have the most exuberant Halloween experience this year with their new interactive Halloween map and "Scare Score" technology. What Is a Scare Score, and How Is It Calculated? Instacart's interactive map tool has collected data from the previous Halloween seasons to determine which cities purchased the most candy, costumes, and dècor based on the shopping data and volume of orders per person in the area. The scare score is ranked out of 100, featuring an index for all categories. You can find your neighborhood scare score by searching your zip code in the tool and viewing how your city ranks in each category. The results for each zip code share the best-seller candies and local faves calculated by the total weight of each candy that was delivered in the zip code in October of 2023. You can boost your city's scare score this year by ordering your candy, costumes, and dècor for delivery. Courtesy of Instacart. Top 10 Scariest Cities In the U.S. Instacart has included "The Most Halloween-iest Zip Codes" in the U.S. based on their scare scores; see if your city made it to the top 10 list below: Draper, UT 84020Lehi, UT84043Scarsdale, NY 10583Birmingham, MIHinsdale, IL 60521 Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 Santa Monica, CA 90402 Rye, NY 10580 Austin, TX 78746 San Jose, CA 95125 Trick-or-Treat Trends: See What Candy Is Most Popular in Your State Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Tell us why! Other Submit