8 Must-Have Fall Décor Items That Designers Love to Buy at Thrift Stores

Ceramics in Autumnal Colors

A beautiful ceramic vase or bowl in a rich, earthy color is easy enough to come by at a thrift store. It may have chips or imperfections, but that can add to its connection to the season. "Autumn colors are warm, and I love how a ceramic vase can complement them," says Carolyn Cerminara, founder and principal designer at Cerminara Design. "Look for a simple shape and a cozy color to echo the warmth you're aiming for."

Brass Candleholders

While pumpkin-scented candles are nice, candleholders and taper candles lend an elegantly rustic look to a space. You can find candleholders at thrift stores for a song, and it's not unusual to stumble across solid brass or crystal. "Fall is a cozy, nesting season—it’s all about creating warmth at home. That’s why I believe you can never have enough candles!" says Cerminara. "I love brass candleholders, especially when they look handmade, which adds to the warmth."

Pewter

Pewter adds a warmth that other silver-toned metals simply don't have, so it looks beautiful next to warm fall tones like rust, pumpkin, and mustard. "There's just something about pewter that feels perfect for fall—it's weathered and distinguished," says Kathy Kuo, CEO and founder of Kathy Kuo Home. "I love a pewter wine chiller for a nice, crisp bottle—shared with good friends on a fall evening."

Woven Baskets

Walk into any thrift store, and chances are you'll see an entire rack or wall of woven and wicker baskets. For a few dollars, you can walk out with one of the best items for setting a seasonal tone. "I love a woven basket for its versatility and its natural texture," says Colleen Bennett, principal at CBB Design Firm. "They're great for holding extra blankets or displaying fall foliage, pine cones, and pumpkins."

Wood Cutting Boards

Wood is another way to add a warm texture that's perfect for fall, and wood carving boards are easy to find at thrift stores. If they're worn out, give them a swipe of mineral oil, and you're back in business. "They're perfect for creating autumn-inspired charcuterie boards, and they can double as a beautiful décor piece when not in use," says Bennett. "The rich wood grain brings a warm, rustic feel that complements fall’s earthy aesthetic."

Pumpkin Stoneware

Pumpkin stoneware—the oven-ready bowls with darling lids—has been on the fall décor scene for several years now. That means some pieces have started to trickle their way into thrift stores, and they're a must-buy when you spot them. "They're perfect for autumn gatherings and combine charm and function," says Bennett. "Glazed stoneware is ideal for both casual and formal fall entertaining."

Moodier Art

Have you ever thought about swapping out your art with the seasons? Interior designer and stylist Justin DiPiero suggests a gallery change as a way to usher in autumn. "I love updating art pieces around my home when the seasons change, especially in the kitchen or dining area," he says. "I look for beautiful, deep burgundy tones for autumn, and a moodier feel."

Often, you can find small oil paintings at thrift stores that are perfect for seasonal decorating. Pick them up whenever you spot one that speaks to you, then build a collection that you can switch around as the world outside begins to change.

Dramatic Candelabras

Want to go for major drama? If you're lucky enough to spot one, go for the statement-making gold candelabra. "It's a stunning find for fall, and the perfect way to make an impact with seasonal decor," says Miranda Cullen, owner and principal at Inside Stories.